RSS

My utopia is dystopia (part 2)

19 Sep

My most recent delve into dystopia fiction was Possession by Elana Johnson.

In the book, Vi, short for Violet, is whisked off to Lock Up after being caught walking with a boy at night.  Such things are forbidden in her world.  She is thrown into a cell with Jag, a boy with dyed hair and tan skin – an obvious rebel.  Soon and with some effort, Vi and Jag escape Lock Up and flee toward a “freer” land, miles away.

Since Vi can feel “tech buzz” and Thinkers always use tech, she can sense danger.  It doesn’t always work though and she and Jag keep ending up having to fight for their lives.

Later, Vi finds out that she can control things and people with just her mind.  She also finds out Jag can control people with his voice.  Still, they hae to fight Thane, the one who controls everything.

***Here begin the spoilers***

When the book opens, Vi is walking with Zenn, her Match.  She loves him deeply, as she reiterates time and again.  But less than 50 pages later, after Vi makes Jag, she falls in love with him.  She knows little about him, yet knows that she loves him.  And, amazingly enough, he loves her back!  Did I mention that these characters are only 15?  Yeah, Vi, that’s just the hormones talking.

As previously mentioned, Vi and Jag are forced to share the same cell when in Lock Up, yet no other cells on their floor are being used.  As I read, I found this hard to believe.  I can stretch my imagination pretty far, but that was too far-reaching.  Vi lives in a society where you can’t walk with a boy yet will force occupancy with one?  Sorry.  Not buying it.  Johnson explains this away later in the book when Vi realizes that Thane wanted her and Jag together to see if they would use their powers.

Ah, yes, the powers.  Once Vi finds out she can control people and things with her mind, there are no more obstacles to overcome.  She can escape any imprisonment, win any fight without so much as breaking a sweat.  Creative Writing 101: take away conflict and you take away any reason to read.  Now, Vi hates being controlled so Johnson could have used this in Vi to have inner conflict.  Instead, Vi whines about it for a few sentences and then continues on.  Some rebel.  She hates what is not useful to her.

Then there’s all the coincidental stuff that happens in the back half of the book.  Vi’s dad had gone missing years before, but then she sees Jag with a book with her dad’s picture on it.  Only, she doesn’t recognize him and only knows it’s him because of the name underneath.  It’s a rebel book about how people can use tech to fight those in power.  Later, as she mentally yells at Thane, the one voice that can enter her mind and someone who has great power, she realizes that it is actually her dad.  Confused?  I’d be surprised if you weren’t.  Oh, and Vi’s older sister died after a year working for the Society.  But lo and behold, she’s alive and working with rebel forces.  She’s using a pseudonym so that no one can find her, especially Thane.  Now, let’s not forget about Zenn, Vi’s Match that she’s totally in love with, even though she’s in love with Jag, too.  It turns out that Zenn and Jag know each other and have for quite some time.  They’ve been working together to get a rebel (Zenn) on the inside.  He passes information along to the rebels to help the fight.  However, at the beginning of the book, he is the one who betrays Vi so that she is arrested, tags her with a homing device, and leads Thane to her.  So is he a rebel or not?  It’s hard to say and when it’s all over, it’s still unclear.

About half-way through the 400 plus page book, I started to get discouraged.  I kept going, though, because I’d gotten so far, I might as well have finished.  Really, the only saving grace in the last half of the book was the end.  Johnson could have made it a happy ending, one that would calm the reader and let her know everything would be okay.  But she ended the book with Thane conquering Vi’s mind, erasing her memory of Jag and forcing her to live a “happy” life with Zenn.  Though she has the feeling that she’s forgotten something important, Vi is content.  The end reminded me of the end of 1984 by George Orwell.

Still, overall, the book was a waste of time.  My theory (as well as a few other people who’ve noted online) is that this book got published because anything dystopian will sell right now.  It’s a shame because I love giving suggestions to teens and parents alike when it comes to books, but I sure as hell don’t recommend this one.

Advertisements
 
Leave a comment

Posted by on September 19, 2011 in Literature, Rants

 

Tags: , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: